This article reviews the new Superman movie, highlighting its struggle with competing themes rather than the controversial interpretation of Superman as an immigrant. Director James Gunn attempts to balance the character's classic 'paragon' image with a more human, fallible portrayal, including a plotline where Lex Luthor tries to discredit him as an undocumented alien. The review notes that Superman has historically been interpreted as an immigrant/refugee, a fact often overlooked by 'outrage media.' The movie is criticized for its frenetic, busy story, subplots, and throwaway gags that try to satisfy too many demographics, leading to a muddled tone despite good action and acting.
Superman has a problem — and it's not that he's an immigrant
Nicholas CageCultureTheatreImmigrants and newcomersRefugees
AI Summary
TL;DR: Key points with love ❤️This article reviews the new Superman movie, highlighting its struggle with competing themes rather than the controversial interpretation of Superman as an immigrant. Director James Gunn attempts to balance the character's classic 'paragon' image with a more human, fallible portrayal, including a plotline where Lex Luthor tries to discredit him as an undocumented alien. The review notes that Superman has historically been interpreted as an immigrant/refugee, a fact often overlooked by 'outrage media.' The movie is criticized for its frenetic, busy story, subplots, and throwaway gags that try to satisfy too many demographics, leading to a muddled tone despite good action and acting.
Trending- 1 1978: Christopher Reeve portrayed Superman in a classic film.
- 2 2018: DC Comics used Superman as a promotional image for World Refugee Day, tweeting '#StandWithRefugees'.
- 3 2018: U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order ending family separation at the border.
- 4 Current: The new Superman movie is released, sparking debate about its interpretation of the character.
- Mixed reception for the new Superman movie
- ongoing debate about character interpretation
- political furor over immigrant themes
What: A review of the new Superman movie, focusing on its thematic struggles and the ongoing debate about Superman's character interpretation, particularly his immigrant status.
When: Published Tuesday (July 8, 2025). New Superman movie released. 1978 (Christopher Reeve film). 2018 (DC Comics tweet).
Where: Metropolis (fictional), Arctic fortress of solitude (fictional), Boravia (fictional), Jarhanpur (fictional, vaguely Middle Eastern, African or South Asian).
Why: To analyze the new Superman film, discuss its narrative choices, and address the controversy surrounding the character's portrayal as an immigrant.
How: The author reviews the film, discusses its themes, and references historical interpretations and public reactions.